Semi-Spontaneous Desert Foray 2006
Our new Canon 5D gets the Utah treatment.





By Christopher Lindley
May 2006
Perfect Kiva Bentwave Tourgroup.
If you've been following the release of Canon's new 5D SLR, you'll have noticed a price drop of about $650 since its release in November of 2005. It's arguable that Nikon's 10.2 MP D200 was giving the 12.8 megapixel (MP) Canon some pressure, because it's still selling for nearly $1000 less than the 5D. While the 5D has a full-frame sensor (meaning that there isn't the field-of-view crop), new SLR buyers will likely not find this enough of a distinction to choose the 5D.

For me, the Nikon/Canon choice was already made: I already own Canon lenses. And I'd been waiting (and waiting) to make the move from the 6 MP D60.  When I learned of Canon's $300 rebate on the 5D, it seemed the time was right.

Another view of Flame House Ruin.

Move your cursor over the images to view!
Must have javascript enabled
Bentwave Tourguide?
It wasn't long after acquiring the 5D that I was asked if I would guide a couple of folks to False Kiva. This was, of course, just the excuse I needed to take what has become an annual event for me:  A springtime trip to Utah.

I met my Right Coast clients, Ken & Dave, at the Mondo Cafe in Moab. I learned that Dave was a retired Kodak engineer who specialized in black & white papers. Indeed, Dave is an imaging expert, making the fact that was also shooting with a 5D very interesting.

I brought along LensWork (issue #46) which has several prints of John Sexton's Anasazi ruins to show Dave, and ask him how you might get prints like that from a digital file. Dave probably thought it was interesting that I was showing him John's work; he said he used to help with Sexton's paper requirements at Kodak. Then Dave said that, in fact, "...we're having dinner with John later in the week". Sigh – I hope they passed along how impressed their False Kiva guide was with John's work.

The Moab Panel.
An Aztec Butte Ruin

We weren't going to False Kiva until later that afternoon, so I suggested that we shoot some ruins in the Island in the Sky's Aztec Butte, which I'd just learned about from Laurent Martrès book "A Guide to Photographing the Southwest - Volume 1". It's picturesque, and what's more, it's quite close to False Kiva. We visited only two of the half-dozen or so ruins on these two small buttes, but both were quite photogenic.

Some will find it disturbing that False Kiva is also in Martrès book. I last visited in November of 2003 (my entry still in the logbook there), and I can tell you that it is much more popular. The trail to it is now quite distinguishable from the lightly trod animal paths that also head the same general direction. And remarkably, one other photographer also showed up while we were there. We stayed late, walking out in near total darkness, and caught some of the last tables at the Moab Brewery before retiring for the evening.

Chessler Park Viewpoint.
Yellow Rock.
Learning about the 5D
False Kiva.

Later, when I looked at some of these pictures, I noticed some vignetting, which I realized likely came from stacking a polarizer on top of a UV/haze filter. Yes, it was now quite clear that I was shooting with a full-frame sensor, perhaps exacerbated by the fact that the viewfinder shows "only" 96% of the image area. As dpreview points out in their 5D review, this is something Canon 20D (and D60) users will have to become aware of when using their 5D with wide-angle lenses at maximum apertures.

In the bright sunlit conditions we were shooting under, I discovered how to use the auto-bracketing feature, but found out that doing manual exposure compensation was perhaps more intuitive. Adjusting ISO speeds is easier than on the D60, and has a maximum range of 1600 (instead of 1000). The D60 user will also like the 5D's focussing:  There are now 9 AF points (and 6 'invisible" ones), and much much better low-light focus. Other advantages are that the 5D powers-on instantaneously, the LCD is significantly larger, and the image processing and write speeds never left me wanting.

Besides these obvious benefits, the physical size and overall similarity to earlier Canon DSLR models may leave the new 5D owner wondering why they spend a small fortune on the upgrade. I'd argue that, once you get past the added functionality, you may not realize what you've got until you work on a large print. I've done a 12x18" 5D print that was rather stunning (even if it was just a test snapshot). I can't wait to see what a professionally-produced 20x30" print looks like, as soon as I get something worth blowing-up to that size.

Grosvenor Arch.
And then there's the 5D RAW conversion in Photoshop CS not!
Imagine my frustration when I couldn't see the 5D images that I'd just brought into Photoshop. That's because Photoshop CS doesn't support 5D RAW conversion! To get 5D support for RAW conversion, you need to upgrade to CS2. This is something I guess I don't get: Isn't it just an (admittedly complex) algorithm for file conversion? If you've got CS, then you either get a third-party RAW converter, or use Adobe's Digital Negative (DNG) software. DNG appears to be Adobe's attempt at a common file format for RAW camera files. Thankfully, Adobe provides the DNG converter for free.
Mule Canyon Ruin #2.
Me?  Sick of ruin-hunting?
I should've known better than to try and do a desert trip in late May. Nothing like visiting the Needles district during 95° F days, shooting under nearly cloudless skies. Did I really careen into the Needles Outpost after a particularly dehydrating hike and plunk down $26 for an array of cold drinks (including a 6-pack of some Uinta India Pale Ale?). I wasn't really dying that much...

Armed with various hiking books, I headed up from Flame House in South Fork of Mule Canyon to check out some of the other ruins. I came across the two shown on the left; the one I called "Mule Canyon #3" is quite inaccessible. The next day brought me into Bullet Canyon – a side canyon of Grand Gulch – where I visited the ruin called "Perfect Kiva", 4.75 miles from the trailhead. Of course, I thought it was 2.2 miles from the trailhead... ahhh, another tiring day, ruin-hunting. What's another 10-mile hike?

After deciding that my feet were sore, I opted for some lighter vacation time, and decided to search out some of the more interesting geologic areas in Laurent Martrès book. I followed the Waterpocket fold through Escalante-Grand Staircase, and went down Cottonwood Canyon, seeking out Laurent's suggestions. I hiked Yellow Rock (along the Cockscomb, pg. 105), ignoring the fact that it was 2:30 in the afternoon and 85°. I also tried to find the "Towers of Silence" (pg. 109) but got somewhat intimidated when the 4WD road appeared to go down a very remote wash, completely contradicting the directions.

Shortly after the washboards of Cottonwood Canyon road, the Jeep decided that it wouldn't close it's rear hatch. Apparently, it was time to head home...
Mule Canyon Ruin #3.